Saturday, April 24, 2010

Fox Bones Episode an Insult to People with Fibromyalgia



I was disappointed, last night, as I watched one of my favorite TV shows, Bones.  

 Episode 18, Predator in the Pool,  was very interesting. Booth and Brennan (Bones) caught the killer, a fourth-grade teacher, who had enacted revenge on a shady self-help guru, Jazz Gunn. Through his seminars, Gunn had promised a cure for pain and fibromyalgia. After taking his seminar nine times, the teacher did not feel any better and felt betrayed by Jazz Gunn and his false promises. An opportunity arose and she killed him. As she was confessing to FBI agent Booth, she stated that after killing him, she has since felt no pain. The clear implication being that her fibromyalgia was now cured.

This conclusion has some humor, but it is at the expense of millions of people who live every day in the pain caused by fibromyalgia. People with fibromyalgia, their families, doctors and scientists around the world have worked hard over the past 30+ years to document the legitimacy of this medical illness.  In 1987, the American Medical Association recognized fibromyalgia as a true illness and a major cause of disability. Despite this recognition, and years of scientific research, many in our society still think of fibromyalgia as a psychological problem. 

This episode of Bones helped to perpetuate this harmful myth. It is not a stretch to believe that the teacher with fibromyalgia would feel desperate and betrayed by the false promises of Jazz Gunn. People often do feel desperate for some type of relief for their never-ending pain. Unfortunately, there is no known cure at this time. Even revenge and murder cannot cure fibromyalgia. 

A Simple Solution to this problem, for the show's writer's, would have been for the highly intelligent Dr. Brennan to add that, "I guess she didn't have fibromyalgia after all".  This would have been consistent with the character's knowledge and avoided the implication that psychological factors, such as needing revenge, could cause fibromyalgia.

A Responsible Solution would be for the producers of Bones to apologize to the millions of people and their families that are  affected by fibromyalgia. This apology could help clarify that fibromyalgia is a true medical illness, not caused or cured by psychological factors.

Bones is still one of my favorites. I hope the writers and researchers can avoid such costly mistakes in the future. A little bit of extra background research can help all of us.

Yours with Care
Michael MacDonald, Ph.D.

4 comments:

  1. i totaly agree. I have suffered from this condtion. I have had major problems dispite over two feet of medical records in getting social security disablity to believe this is a deblitating condtion.
    to say the show was insulting is a small thought i was outraged. And then it was allowed to be reran.
    I have been evaluated by so many doctors all say i havent got mental problems only physical ones along with the pain issues. I face my fears daily. the fear of falling the fear of migrains for days the fear any meds will give me yet another reaction are all fears i face. I dont think it was fair to fibromyalgia paitens to say as in the show that we can stop the pain by facing the fear.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A passing mention on another Fox program, Glee, on 8 February 2011, has me wondering if Fox still thinks Fibromyalgia is funny.

    In the episode "Silly love songs," Sue Sylvester tries to enlist Britney's sympathy for an inanimate object---a circus cannon---by stating that the mommy cannon can't work because it has Fibromyalgia.

    This is a flippant little reference and yet implies an understanding that Fibromyalgia is indeed disabling.

    Interestingly, the episode ends with two students getting mononucleosis, a disease which is often the viral trigger for chronic diseases later diagnosed as Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and/or Fibromyalgia.

    In a perfect world, this would be the first glimmer of a great change in Fox's attitude, and we would learn in upcoming episodes that researchers have done their job right.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My dear brothers and sisters, I am about to tell you how God through the help of an herbal doctor saved the life of my only brother. Fredrick Machel is my name I live in Boston, USA. My brother's name is John Machel. My only brother four years ago fell ill, and at first was diagnosed of high fever which resulted into him having critical health issues. Two years ago, he was diagnosed of FIBROMYALGIA he was having chronic muscle pain, fatigue, sleep problems, and painful tender points or trigger points, we tried so many medications but none worked for him. I search the internet for possible cure but none was found until i came across a note of testimony made by a man named James Watt on the internet where he claimed that a herbal doctor by name Doctor Uwadia Amenifo cured his cousin of a chronic disease that is worst than FIBROMYALGIA. So I tried to reach the testifier James Watt to ask if there could be any hope from this herbal man towards assisting my brother to finding cure to his ailment. So he emailed me after two days and gave me the contact details of the said doctor. So I emailed the doctor and explained to him what my only brother is going through. And he said no problem that my brother will be healthy again. At first I doubted him because he said it so easily, and at this stage I was so curious and I asked him what he meant by my brother will be healthy again. So then he told me that he have some powerful herbs that can cure FIBROMYALGIA. To cut the long story short, I akin to his advise and counseling. So he told me all I would do, and after all arrangement was made, he started sending herbs to my brother. Behold just two weeks after my brother started using his herbs he began to improve, and as I speak to you today my brother is healthy and free from FIBROMYALGIA. So when I see that my brother have regained back his health I contacted Doctor Uwadia to tell him of the good news. And he asks me to help tell people across the world how powerful his herbs can be. And that is exactly what I am doing now. Brothers and sisters i want you all to help me say a big thanks to God and also to Doctor Uwadia Amenifo. He is really a wonderful herbal doctor. So in case you wish to treat yourself or your close one of diseases please i strongly recommend Doctor Uwadia Amenifo to you all. You can either reach him on his email (doctoruwadiaamenifo@gmail.com), or you call him on his cell (+2349052015874). God bless you all.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Am Susan from Sweden I want to share a testimony on how this great man Dr Ekpiku help me to heal my herpes virus is the solution to herpes cure,Since last 4 months I have being a Herpes patient.it was confirm I have be in several hospital but no one can cure it one day I was browsing through the Internet I saw a testimony on how Dr Ekpiku from Africa healer and i saw so many testimony on blogger how is cure a lady called Grace and i asked her if she was cure by Dr Ekpiku,what she said was yes that is heal and be free for herpes,she told me that there is a great spell caster that can cure my herpes Virus,I asked her if she had his email, she gave me his email, so I contact him and i told him I have Herpes virus,and I asked for solutions, he started the herbal remedy for my health, he sent me the medicine,and i start taking the medicine as prescribed by him and 2 week later i was cured from HERPES, Dr. Ekpiku truly you are great healer, do you need his help also? Why don't you contact him through ekpikuspellhomeofgrace@gmail.com or his cell number +2348073673757,I’m the happiest girl in the world thank you Dr Ekpiku he cure any type of disease HIV/AIDS,CANCER,diabetes,ALS, Hepatitis B, HERPES, PVC/ through his via email;ekpikuspellhomeofgrace@hotmail.com.

    ReplyDelete